Last year's World Hurdle was a gimme for Big Buck's but there is a
new kid on the block in the shape of Grand Crus and Thursday's renewal (3.20) is
now one of the most eagerly awaited races of the entire Festival.
2010 Result: Big Buck's, trained by Paul Nicholls and ridden by
Ruby Walsh, 5/6 SP
Key Trends:
The previous year's winner has
returned four times in the past decade and their overall record stands at three
wins and one second. Clearly, that speaks in the favour of Big Buck's, although
he would be the first horse to win three consecutive staying hurdle crowns
(Inglis Drever missed out in 2006 due to injury) if successful.
He's been off the track since winning the Long Walk Hurdle in December and
that Newbury race has provided the winner four times in the past 20 years,
although the Cleeve Hurdle, won by Grand Crus, has now usurped it as the best
trial - three of the last four winners ran in the Cheltenham Grade 2 event.
This is not a great race for the Irish with just four winners since the
mid-1980s and none since Dorans Pride in 1996 - Mourad and Fiveforthree look
their best chances of breaking that run. However, neither of that pair ran at
last year's Festival and that is a negative considering all but two of the last
17 winners had been in action 12 months earlier.
Big-priced winners are rare - six of the last seven runnings have gone to
horses in the first five in the betting - while French-breds have won five of
the past nine runnings and it's long odds-on we will get another one this year
with both Big Buck's and Grand Crus (along with his stablemate Ashkazar) falling
into that bracket.
Major Players:
In nearly two years since he
outgunned Punchestowns here, Big Buck's has dominated the
staying hurdle scene and he has a perfect 10-10 record since reverting to
hurdles after unseating his rider in the 2008 Hennessy. In that time, he has not
had a hard race since hitting a flat spot (not for the first time) in the 2009
Long Walk Hurdle at Newbury, while his toughest opponent was Punchestowns in the
2009 World Hurdle - the latter built up what looked an unassailable lead only to
crumple when Big Buck's drew alongside on the flat. His trainer Paul Nicholls
has been quoted as saying he's the most talented horse in the yard, which is
some compliment, and he's quite rightly a short-priced favourite for this, with
no bigger than 11/10 on offer.
He'd be a lot shorter but for the emergence of Grand Crus,
whose Cleeve Hurdle romp was one of the most visually impressive of the season.
After starting the season on a handicap of mark 126 (in hindsight, he was a
certainty on his reappearance here in November), he's climbed to a mark of 169,
which is just 5lb shy of Big Buck's', and there is surely more to come after
just six starts over hurdles. That could be seen as a negative considering that
eight of the last 10 winners had run between eight and 20 times over hurdles,
but it's also a negative for Big Buck's, who is at the other end of the scale
with 23 hurdle starts under his belt. Of more of a concern is the possibility of
good ground as his trainer David Pipe considers him a soft ground horse, while
some have questioned his ability to see out the race given he's a headstrong
sort who likes to race prominently.
Lively Outsiders:
Ireland are attempting to
spoil the party with Mourad and Fiveforthree
and the former, in particular, can be given an each-way chance. He's done all
his winning in Ireland, which makes the form hard to evaluate, but you can't
argue with the ease of his victories over 3m on ground softer than he likes, and
we know he handles Cheltenham as he finished third in one of the hottest
Triumphs we've seen - Zaynar and Walkon finished ahead of him, with Starluck and
Reve De Sivola fourth and sixth respectively. His trainer Willie Mullins thinks
he's still improving and you have to sit up and take notice.
Betting Advice:
Tactics and the run of the race
will play a crucial role in the outcome. If it's a fast-run race, that will play
into the hands of Big Buck's, who arguably has the greater stamina. If it's more
of a speed test, Grands Crus might well beat him, although the Pipe horse needs
the field to go fast enough to allow him to settle. It's a fascinating contest
and one I could easily just watch and savour, although I admit to having a small
ante post investment on Grands Crus at 9/2 after the Cleeve. If you are not
already on, he looks a bit cramped now at around 5/2 and the best piece of
advice might be to back MOURAD each-way at around 9/1 or at 4/1
in bet365's 'w/o Big Buck's' market (1/4 odds, 1.2.3), which is surely a bet to
nothing.